Chris H.

Love it! Full menu, full bar, daily specials. Great local place to go out for dinner,lunch, drinks, whatever. Can call ahead and just pick up food to go too. Great friendly service, quick too no waiting forever even when it's full.


Beth Y.

Good food, reasonable prices... All Italian. Family atmosphere, even with the bar right there.


Joanna S.

It's what I expected, nothing fancy or expensive but good for a quick bite and pizza was unique, different than what I have had but good.
9/14/18 ... Came back here for lunch and I was blown away by their half turkey sub basket ... It's really the perfect amount of food and extremely tasty!


Michael B.

Very friendly atmosphere. Well priced food and drinks. Great pizza.


What our customers are saying about Casey's

Google Ranking

Trip Advisor Ranking

Yelp Ranking

Joanne S.

A great family restaurant. The food is consistently good and reasonably priced.


Jeremy L.

Great local hangout and a good place for lunch. Very nice staff and good food.


Walt B.

My family loves Casey's, they have awesome pizza and my daughter loves the hot pepper cheese balls!!

Marita L.

The food was incredible and the service was shockingly fast (they had a party in the side room and it didn't effect our service at all). And the prices were incredibly reasonable.


Patty D.

Grew up with this restaurant! Friendly, good food and reasonable. Good place to catch up with friends. Even friends from years back return for their pizza or hoagies!


Jason P.

Casey's has pretty affordable and great food. I usually get takeout, but the venue is alright. They're Antipasta salads are the best around and their pizza is a different take than other pizza joints. You can also get both for under 20 bucks and feed a handful of people.

Aron E.

The best new york style pizza in Pittsburgh. Kills anything on the local news rankings. Super affordable. Great atmosphere. Stellar service, Always! Need I say more? Seriously, the thin pizza is the BEST NYC style around. Trust me I've researched. Only bad thing is they close on lots of holidays.


Great pizza. One of the best pizza restaurants in Shaler. Their toppings are fresh and their hoagies are very delicious. Had their homemade Provolone wheels which were excellent. The atmosphere and service was great.

Ed S.

Nice little place , very clean, half decent bar area and a solid draft list. Tried the meatball hoagie and bbq wings. Both were solid, wings were crispy and super tasty. Grilled chicken salad was really big, lots of cheese and chicken and marinated tomatoes which make the whole salad. Very nice waitress who took care of everything we needed. Great food for the low prices. Will be back.

Sandra W.

Asbsolutely love this place. This is a regular place for the family. The food is fantastic. A wide variety for everyone. The wait staff are great too. I definitely recommend this family restaurant!


Patrick P.

The little bar that could!

Really it is a restaurant. When you walk in the door you notice a wrap around bar.

I ordered the pizza and had a couple of draft beers. The bartenders were very nice. Being a traveler, bartenders provide me the most non-work conversation for the day. The bartenders were fun to be around and played or picked on all the regulars which was nice.

The pizza was good but nothing to jump out of a tree over. The cost of the whole evening was very cheap.

I will definitely go back to the restaurant / bar.

Food - Pretty good and well worth the price
Service - Awesome - friendly folks who were engaging and there when they needed to be
Price - Cheap - if you are on a budget - you should check this gem out.


Gina K.

A great place to get a drink with friends after work. There bar is well priced, the wait staff is awesome! The food is better than usual bar food, because it is also an Italian restaurant, and the food is good.


David K.

A great place for families to pick up a great meal at an affordable price. The pizza is the specialty along with the great sandwiches and salads. There is usually a mix of local youth teams after games and adults looking for a relaxing evening out. The staff is fantastic and this is a great place to dine in or carry out!